I travel to London roughly once a fortnight, and go by train so I can work. The line was run by GNER, but has been taken over by National Express.
Ticket prices are high and getting higher, and trains are always packed full of people. Some people end up standing having paid £140 for a standard class ticket between York and London!! (As an aside, if two people travel first class to London now, they'd actually save money by getting a chauffeur driven Mercedes for the day to take them door to door!)
My treat to myself is that I eat in the restaurant car, with a nice English breakfast on the way down and my evening meal on the way back. The food has always been pretty good, and the service very chatty and friendly.
But now it seems the cost cutting measures are coming in - and there's a lesson here for everyone in business. Even the smallest cost cutting gets noticed and breeds resentment. People aren't daft and know when they're paying more for less.
My breakfast today was described as a Full British Breakfast with 'Fried or scrambled eggs, bacon, sausage, a grilled field mushroom, baked beans, fried bread and tomato'. Yum. It was £15.95, but I've got a busy day ahead, and it is my one treat after all.
When it arrives, there is half a mushroom. That's right, just half.
I notice that everyone is getting just half a mushroom.
Now, I'm in a cheeky mood, so I ask if its possible to have the other half of mine seeing as it was described as 'a field mushroom' (I'm no Victor Meldrew, I'm just teasing), and it turns out this is what they have to give us - portion control.
So National Express have saved the price of half a mushroom. I bet some accountant somewhere is very proud of that bit of portion control, and has the spreadsheet to prove it. But suddenly my breakfast feels less like a treat, and more like a con. It was just enough to turn me off the idea, and I'll certainly have it less, and maybe not at all.
So was it really worth the saving?
This is the problem with cost control. You're never actually aware of the adverse affect it has on your customers, and what you might be losing out on as a result.
It's much better to focus on increasing sales. The train was packed with businesspeople, but the restaurant car wasn't busy - so they'd be better persuading more people to try it and use it.
So remember, when your accountants start talking about your equivalent of giving customers half a mushroom, think of what your customers will think as a result - and see if there is a way to increase sales instead.
Your focus should always be on improving what you give to customers, and therefore making more sales for more money, rather than reducing what you give.

Wed, 01/23/2008 - 15:33
Hi Steve,
Agreed... wouldn't it have been better to supplement the breakfast with some freshly ground, freshly brewed coffee?
As well, at that price:
- the sausage should be a premium quality organic sausage, no Tesco Value bangers
- the eggs should be free range
- And they should be ashamed of themselves for filling up the plate cheaply with baked beans!!
Perhaps they could even offer a variety of breakfasts - e.g. American pancakes / fresh fruit salad / croissants and pains au chocolat?
Bring the customers in, don't drive them away!
And I'm an accountant!!
M
Fri, 01/25/2008 - 13:01
Well, all credit to National Express, I received the following email:
So I've got back to them. There were also some other issues with the service that I didn't mention in the blog because they weren't relevant to the article on portion control.
It's excellent that National Express are on the ball with how their service is being discussed on the web, and ready to respond.
Mon, 02/25/2008 - 10:45
I desperately want to avoid becoming Victor Meldrew here... but this original post was about the perils of portion control - drawing a larger lesson from what was a very small issue.
In the email above National Express East Coast said that they hadn't introduced portion control - but I gave their breakfast another go the other week and sure enough, half a mushroom.
But a more serious issue on that journey was the staff seemed to view customers as a real inconvenience, and treated one other customer very rudely indeed. I wasn't impressed at all.
is it downhill now for the East Coast mainline service?
Tue, 06/17/2008 - 13:29
I travel every week to Edinburgh and have always used the restaurant for breakfast.
The menu has now been tweaked and within a week of the change I noticed the restaurant is now usually empty at breakfast, whereas a month ago it was hard to get a seat some days.
The black pudding has now been halved, NO BAKED BEANS which has left the full english rather dry and unedible, oh and it went up in price!
Fruit cocktail has vanished to be replaced with an item of fruit.
Even the staff admit that the menu has changed for the worse and yesterday told me to smugle beans onboard and the chef will include them in the breakfast for me!
Tue, 07/08/2008 - 22:32
Hi Mike
yes - I see what you mean! I decided to try breakfast on the way to London once more the other week, and baked beans have gone as part of the cost cutting. How much does a dollop of baked beans cost??!
The fruit cocktail has gone too. And the price has gone up!
The staff seem to be quite embarrassed about all this (and embarrassed and annoyed by the fact that their expensive new handheld gadgets never work anymore, so they're having to write out paper receipts and put cards through an old fashioned imprint machine).
National Express seems to be having some issues.
I've also noticed that this seems to have led to less people using the dining car.
I've given up on breakfasts now, but may give the dinner coming home one last try tomorrow night! Fingers crossed for me. :)
Post new comment